Teacher Tuesday #1 || In which I review The Book Whisperer by Donalyn Miller

I am a loud-and-proud, avid reader.


Pride and Prejudice reading gif

Honestly, it’s one of my favorite things about myself, even though it sometimes leads to awkward conversations:

“So, what do you like to do in your free time?”
“Um . . . read.”
*proceeds to just look at me* (based on real-life happenings)

Being an avid reader isn’t seen as a good thing by most people – the stereotype is that readers are antisocial and awkward introverts (okay, so that does describe me 93% of the time, but that’s not the point). But being an avid reader can revolutionize your teaching. That’s one of the points Donalyn Miller makes in The Book Whisper

Thankfully, I have a strong background in reading. My mom encouraged reading while I was going up, and my grandmas always had books on hand and were always telling us stories. I had amazing teachers who helped shape my love of reading by sharing their favorite authors or books with me, teachers who loved to talk about what they were reading. One former teacher loves Jane Austin, who is now one of my favorite authors. My Senior English teacher is now a published author who gave me advice on writing and planted the crazy idea of earning a Master’s into my head before I even graduated high school.

I read The Book Whisper for the first time last summer. Alongside the examples of my former teachers, this book has strongly influenced my philosophy of teaching.

Review of The Book Whisperer by Donalyn Miller

Who is it for?

Donalyn Miller is a reading teacher, so much of The Book Whisperer is based on her experiences in that field. But if you’re a pre-calc or biology teacher, don’t quit on me yet!

True, reading and Language Art teachers will gain the most out of Miller’s strategies and activities, but her reflections are good for all teachers to read. She focuses on the importance cultivating a love of reading in students and meeting students where they are, which is something I believe needs to happen in every subject area.

What I Loved

Model, Model, Model

Miller mentions multiple times (haha, alliteration – I’m so smart), the importance of teachers modeling the behavior they expect students to have. If we want our students to be life-long readers, we need to show them how to do that. When Miller’s students are reading, she’s reading. Evidence suggests there is a link between the reading habits of teachers and the reading achievements of their students.

Since Miller doesn’t use whole-group novel instruction, one way she encourages teachers to model is by reading classic works aloud. This is one of the reasons I placed a high priority on reading quality works aloud in all my classes (I do wish I would’ve put a higher priority on this – it’s easy to push reading aloud off to the side when you feel pressed for time).

With my 5th/6th grade reading class, I read Beauty and the Beast (the original fairytale) aloud as we finished up a characterization unit. I read the story aloud to them, and together we noted the different characters – who was dynamic and who was static? Who was a major character and who were some minor characters? Who was the protagonist? Why do you think that? 

After we finished reading it, the students had a deeper understanding of characterization and the different types of characters. They all did great on their final test and could point out examples of charaterization in their own novels. 

Create the Atmosphere

If you teach reading, you need to have books everywhere. Think about it – science classrooms look like science classrooms because of the microscopes and beakers and such. Miller emphasizes the importance of creating a room that screams “We read in here!”

One of my best friends (yo, Amy) does an amazing job of this in her classroom. I volunteered in her classroom recently, and she has books everywhere. Everywhere. I’ve lost count of how many times we’ve gone shopping for “just a couple books,” and she finishes with arms full of new books for her kids. All of her students have books on their desks. She reads books her students are reading. She places a huge priority on her students having time to read, both independently and aloud. The whole atmosphere in her classroom echoes what Miller teaches – the atmosphere of the classroom needs to make it evident that reading is important.

Question and Reflect

“If you ever think you have all the answers, it’s time to retire” (pg. 14). Everything that Miller teaches through The Book Whisperer is self-discovered through research and trial-and-error. She noticed that her students weren’t excelling, so she found different approaches to her teaching style. Her personal reflections teach us to question our practices – are our activities and assessments actively contributing to our students’ growth, or are we only doing them because that’s what we’ve always done.

Be Yourself

Over and over again, Miller stresses the importance of being real and honest with your students. If you love reading, great! Let them know that; model that love for them. Do you struggle with finding time to read? Perfect – tell your students that, too. 

The ultimate goal in any subject area should be to teach students to take ownership of their learning and giving them the tools to do so. Miller argues that it’s in building relationships and modeling the life of a lifelong reader (or learner) that will encourage students to do the same.


Scattered throughout The Book Whisperer are little gems of information that I find extremely useful. Miller shares strategies and activities she uses in her classroom. I found Chapter 6 to be the most beneficial – she talks about traditional strategies and provides and explains alternatives. There are three appendixes in the back, which have forms and lists available for use. She also includes student examples and quotes to show her activities in action. I gain a lot of knowledge through reading; however, I learn to apply that knowledge through watching other people. By including all her examples, Miller helped me understand how to implement her strategies.

Final Thoughts

Most everything Miller teaches in The Book Whisper has contributed to who I am as a reader and a teacher. There are a couple areas where my views differ, but I still respect her thoughts and reasons. For example, Miller doesn’t like using whole-class novel instruction and opts for book groups instead. As a novice teacher, I lean toward using whole-class novels, because it’s easier for me to teach strategies and model when we’re all reading the same thing. I think book groups are important and make a good extension after reading a whole-class novel.

Who knows, maybe those views will change as I gain more experience.

Even if you’re not a reading teacher, if you haven’t read The Book Whisper yet, please do. You’ll find something worth your while in there. And it’s a fairly quick read.

I'm reading a book

Self-reflection time!! Do you see yourself as a reader now?? Why or why not? Chat about it below!

4 thoughts on “Teacher Tuesday #1 || In which I review The Book Whisperer by Donalyn Miller

  1. What do you think about book alternatives?
    I don’t read as much as I used to. If I want something for work, well-sourced articles and podcasts are more to-the-point and up-to-date. For established topics, YouTube videos are more engaging. If I want a story, a video game is immersive as well as choose-your-own-adventure. If you like the long story arc, find an amazing TV show.
    Books still have a place. A book can cover a niche topic in depth. Some have risen up and still cast their shadow on a subject. Classic originals are always worthwhile.
    Is this amazing technology good or bad for us? Why do you read?


    1. I agree with you. There are a ton of blogs I read (both for entertainment and information). I’m not a huge podcast person, but I’ll listen to Ted Talks fairly often. One reason I love video games is because of the storylines and the critical thinking that’s involved in the more strategic ones.

      I feel like the one thing you get from reading that you can’t get anywhere else is the empathy aspect. Reading allows you to connect with characters on a deep level. Studies have shown that people who read fiction tend to be more empathetic and understanding than those who don’t. Books show you another way of life – Anna Karenina taught me more about Russian culture than any textbook; the Redwall series taught me that raccoons are only in North America and how abbeys functioned. I also think books are good escapes – it’s a way to shut out the world and immerse yourself into another reality. I guess video games gives that, too, but there’s not a video game version of Little Women (haha)!

      Hopefully that answers your questions. Next week I’m planning on writing a post that is more research based as to why reading is important. I’ll touch on some of these points in that. Can’t wait for you to read it!


  2. Empathy is an interesting concept. I’ll have to think about that.

    For showing you another way of life, movies and TV series may be more effective. They have so magnitudes more resources at their disposal than a struggling writer. Resources not just for cool effects, but to research and to experiement. If a picture is worth a thousand words, what about a series of frames with audio? I learned more about the general life of a politician through House of Cards than I would through any book.

    But maybe because there is so much money involved in Hollywood, their stories are less true than literature. Lauren and I watch Criminal Minds. We learn things from that fiction: what makes people tick, how the FBI operates, etc. How much of that is true and how much is made-for-TV?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I agree with you, but I think reading allows for more personal creativity and more mental stimulation. I have to qualms with watching a TV show or movie. But there’s something about reading a book, and then imagining that in your head. You’re given the opportunity to fill in between the lines by visualizing what you’ve read. You can’t really do that with TV shows. A character looks the way the actor does; whereas, in a book, the character might be described as having sweeping brown hair and handsome blue eyes, but you ultimately get to picture what that looks like in your head. Does that make sense?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s